[DriveBy]

After Mr James' sterling performance on Saturday night. :-& :-&


Is he fit to carry on (rhetorical question) or who do we replace him with ?

(Unfortunately Billy the Fish is not a real person, so is unlikely to qualify)

 

[Hincey]

robinson by a mile....

 

[Ice Maiden]

hmmmmmmmm not a clue.......the Goalie from my sons under 16s team is bloody good,.....wipe the floor with Mr james lol

 

[ZRVic]

Theres no "other" or "none of the above" so i can't vote!!

 

[PCNutty]

What about Ian Walker ! right i'm not voting

 

[Big Slick]

..........SEAMAN baby yeah!

 

[yellow-peril]

hes in the team because sven likes his misses , if you now what i mean , its possible sven working through all the ladies :lol: :lol: :lol:

 

[DriveBy]

Theres no "other" or "none of the above" so i can't vote!!

Thats why I put the "couldn't care less they are all crap" option in :smile: :grin:

 

[hoogie]

mARTIN

BY FAR THE BEST KEEPER IN THE PREM (ENGLISH) LAST SEASON

 

[Pimptastic]

Robinson!

 

[Da_One]

tbh dunno why James is No1 in the 1st place??
we all knew he was nick named calamity James from the days of Liverpool.

Robinson is the best English GK at the mo.

Kirkland has this big reputation as the next best successor... lol even though he doesn't play..soo how can he b, not even proven GK @ the highest level.
Walker.... hmm even hes better than James and hes in Div one now.

 

[chrisyjuk]

Sven's blind loyalty to players who constantly play shit is hampering the england team. What happens if James breaks his leg? None of his replacements have enough experiance because in a friendly they get 45 mins at the most!

 

[DriveBy]

Apologies for possibly missing out someones favourite keeper, I was just trying to keep the list more manageable, hence the "they're all crap" option.

Kirkland IS good, but probably too injury prone, that's why I didn't list him.

Ian Walker, is on the fringes anyway.

One point that I did find ridiculous was made in the studio on Sky after the match, by Andy Gray and Teddy Sherringham.

I think Richard Keys asked "Why not play Paul Robinson or Nigel Martyn".
The reply was - because they don't have enough experience !!!!

Firstly - they both have LOADS of experience as Premier league keepers - alledgedly the best league in the World.

Secondly - How the hell do you get international experience, without playing in internationals ?

Thirdly - who told David James he was a goalkeeper anyhow? Who is his coach, Billy Smart ?

My personal choice would be Paul Robinson. Young and hungry for success and very talented.

I have no biased interest in his selection either, I am a Blade's supporter - our keeper is Irish (and erratic).

 

[chrisyjuk]

I have no biased interest in his selection as I am a Blade's supporter and our keeper is Irish.

And fat 8-[

Not that being a Leeds fan makes my opinion biased

 

[Da_One]

oh I'm bias :smile:
Spurs fan here :lol:

Robinson and then Walker as No2 :wink:

 

[DriveBy]

I have no biased interest in his selection as I am a Blade's supporter and our keeper is Irish.

And fat 8-[

Not that being a Leeds fan makes my opinion biased

Listen - he may be fat, but he didn't lose any weight when we played your lot recently - you never gave him anything to do.

He was in his deckchair reading the Sunday paper most of the match :lol:

We could have played goalie-wag :grin: :grin:

 

[chrisyjuk]

Tell me about it, Robinson et al did well to get out while they could!

 

[Spalding]

Ryan Green, just needs a move to a bigger club

 

[Ageratum]

Chris Kirkland would be my choice !!

 

[Gold Rover]

Chris Kirkland would be my choice !!

big up that man ! only answer